Industrial Relations Documentation

Industrial Relations Documentation

Discipline, Incapacity & Performance

Appeal Against Outcome

Once a case is submitted, Frappe's standard Cancel is blocked for everyone except System Manager. The way to reopen a decided case is a formal Appeal Against Outcome.

Drafting and deciding

Create the appeal with Actions → Appeal Against Outcome on the submitted case. HR Managers and IR Officers can prepare and submit appeals (IR Users can only read them). The appeal's own Actions menu, with Write Outcome Report for a written outcome of the appeal, is shown to HR Managers.

An Appeal Against Outcome: outcome being appealed, decision Upheld, procedural grounds and details

An appeal records:

  • the Outcome Being Appealed (read-only, from the case), the employee and their Branch;
  • the Appeal Decision: Pending, Upheld, Partially Upheld or Dismissed (it can't be submitted while Pending);
  • the Grounds for Appeal (Procedural, Substantive, New Evidence) and Details of Grounds for Appeal;
  • supporting documents.

Confirming what will happen

When you submit, ir explains exactly what the decision will do before anything changes:

The confirmation: Upheld means the decision is set aside, and lists the documents that will be cancelled and the amended copy that will be created

  • Dismissed: nothing changes. The original decision and sanction stand.
  • Upheld or Partially Upheld:
    1. The most recently submitted sanction is cancelled, which reverses its effect (reinstating a dismissed employee, lifting a suspension, undoing a demotion).
    2. The case itself is cancelled.
    3. An amended copy of the case is created as a new draft, ready for a fresh outcome.

The amended draft created after the appeal was upheld

From here the cycle (NTA Enquiry, Written Outcome, sanction) can start again against the amended case. The appeal itself can also have its own Written Outcome of Appeal.

Next: Schedule of Offences.

Last updated 2 weeks ago
Was this helpful?
Thanks!